The idea that anal sex always hurts is a common myth, not unlike the idea that vaginal intercourse always hurts the first time. Neither of these is true. The truth is. Watch First Time Painful Anal video on xHamster, the largest sex tube site with tons of free Italian Anal Time & First Time Anal porn movies! Spoiler: The myth that it always hurts is completely untrue. Dr. McBride compared first-time anal to first-time vaginal sex. More than likely, you.